Examining the proposed amendments to the Lagos State High Court Civil Procedure Rules -Abdulrasheed Ibrahim

Precisely on 30th September 2018, I did an article titled: LAMENTING THE SLOW DISPENSATION OF JUSTICE. On 17th October 2018, the Lagos Sate Judiciary organized a seminar to shed light on the proposed amendments to the Lagos State High Court Civil Procedure Rules 2012 as part of the activities marking its 2018/2019 Legal Year. Although I have not been opportune to see the draft of the proposed new Rules, but from the available information here and there one can deduce some features which the new Rules are coming up with. While I am adopting my earlier submissions contained the said article, I want us to here look at some of these proposed amendments. But first let me link this article to the previous one where I had said:

 

“…Some years later, precisely in 2012, Lagos State Judiciary further improved on its frontloading rules wherein it changed the Pre-Trial Conference (PTC) under the 2004 Rules to the Case Management Conference (CMC) under the 2012 Rules. With all these changes and innovations made to improve on the speedy dispensation of justice, the desire for quick dispensation of justice is still found wanting. You can only know when you institute an action but cannot be sure when it will actually come to an end.”

 

The desire for quick dispensation of justice must be a serious concern to everyone. Among the proposed amendments to the 2012 Rules are that

  • failure to comply with the Pre-action protocol will render the originating process null and void;
  • a party that is not ready to participate in a matter already fixed for trial without valid reason will have a cost of not less than N100,000 awarded against him;
  • if a lawyer frustrates the hearing of an interlocutory application, he will have a cost of not less than N50,000 awarded against him;
  • a case that is abandoned by a lawyer for six months can be struck out by the Court suo motu;
  • daily default payment will increase from N200 to N1000;
  • a matter of extreme urgency may not need to comply with the Pre-action protocol if the Court is satisfied;
  • substituted service by electronic means especially in fundamental human rights matters is now acceptable;
  • video conference is now allowed during the taking of evidence;
  • page limit is now introduced as final addresses of each party should not be more than 20 pages while reply on point of law should not be more than 5 pages.

 

The above are just the tip of the iceberg that I have been able to come up with. While one must still accept the fact that the Lagos State Judiciary is usually the pacesetter in most things that are innovative in our judicial system in Nigeria, it must be noted that some of these proposed amendments have been in practice in some other Courts like the increased daily penalty fee, service by electronic means and page limit which are now in vogue at the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, Federal High Court and the National Industrial Court. If all these would checkmate and put an end to all the lamentations against slow dispensation of justice, that will be a very welcome development.

 

If the truth must be told, one of the problems that confront the successful operation of some of these Rules of Courts is lack of unanimity in the understanding of a particular set of Rules. Now let us start with the Pre-action protocol. By the amendment being proposed, it seems the status of Pre-action protocol as it is today under the 2012 is not certain, that is to say whether failure to comply with it is an irregularity or a nullity; hence the proposal being made that failure to comply with it as set out in Form 1 would render the Court processes null and void. In reality, some Courts before now have struck out cases that they believe did not comply with the said Form 1.

 

For instance, I was involved in a case where a customer sued his banker on the allegation that the Bank manipulated his account on a loan transaction between him by the Bank building into his account illegal interests that could not be justified. The customer got a forensic expert to audit his account with the Bank. The expert eventually came up with a comprehensive report which was sent to the Bank with the demand to rectify the same but the bank ignored the demand. When I was briefed by the customer and I read through the forensic report as well as other correspondences, I wrote to the Bank clearly stating our demand based on all the documents made available to me and that if the Bank failed to meet our demand, we would be left with no option than to approach the Court of law for appropriate remedy.

 

The Bank despite being in receipt of our letter did not reply the same. We subsequently filed an action in Court against the Bank. In the processes we filed before the Court, we accompanied them with the Pre-action protocol stating all the steps we had taken before coming to Court but did not attach to the sworn Pre-action protocol form, the last correspondence which was the letter summarising all the steps we had taken before filing the suit since we believed we have pleaded them in the Statement of Claim, listed and frontloaded them as part of the documents we were to rely on at the trial. The Counsel to the Defendant filed Preliminary objection with written address along with their Statement of Defence contending that we did not comply with the Pre-action protocol and that as such the Court lacks jurisdiction to hear our case. The Court did not buy our arguments contained in our Counter-Affidavit and written address in support that when issue of jurisdiction is raised the appropriate process to look into is the Statement of Claim and that the Defendant rather than allowing the matter to proceed to trial and put up their defence were  indulging  in technicality. Even our reference to Order 3 Rule 2 (2) did not save our suit from being struck out by the presiding Judge on the ground that our suit was a nullity and incompetent. There are Courts that do not entertain such preliminary objections and will have such objection dismissed.

 

I am personally of the view that the requirements expected to be complied with by the Claimant under the preamble to the Rules as far as pre-action protocol is concerned seem to put the Claimant at the mercy of an arrogant Defendant. It is more or less asking the Claimant to be begging the Defendant to have settlement with the Claimant on a matter of obligation on the part of the Defendant. Perhaps this is the reason why the amendment is being proposed that some urgent matters may be exempted from complying with the pre-action protocol forms if the Court is satisfied that compliance will occasion great harm.

 

Before the introduction of Pre-action protocol form, there are laws that make it mandatory for a Claimant who wants to institute legal action against statutory bodies to issue out pre-action notices to such bodies before Court proceedings are commenced. In an action for the recovery of debt, the Claimant is expected to first issue a letter of demand. This has now become settled law as in the case of Kolo Vs. First Bank of Nigeria PLC.[1]

 

“It is trite law that in an action for the recovery of debt, the cause of action accrues upon demand for the payment of the debt. If no demand is made, a cause of action does not arise and no action can be commenced.”

 

Also in tenancy matter where the landlord wants to recover possession of his premises from the tenant, he is expected to issue statutory notices as prescribed by the law. Where all these are done as stipulated by law and relevant materials are placed before the Court, I am of the view that there should be an easy access to the Court for those who desire justice through court proceedings without further hindrance. For a Court to insist that a suit is null and void merely because those materials are not particularly attached to the Pre-action form will amount to nothing but a high level of technicality. Can a Pre-action protocol form take the place of Writ of Summons, Statement of Claim and the accompanying processes in a suit? Such an omissionn should be seen as mere irregularity rather than for the action to be declared null and void.

 

While people should be encouraged to embrace the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanism, the right of people who think otherwise must be equally respected. There are several instances where parties go to the Mediation Centre and after arriving at settlement and come up with Memorandum of Understanding, you later see some of them defaulting by refusing to discharge their part of the obligations.  You then see the aggrieved party going back to Court seeking for the Memorandum of Understanding to be entered as the judgment of the Court for the purpose of enforcement.

 

Another aspect of the 2012 Rules on which there seems to be is no unanimity on its proper application is Order 6 Rules 6 and 7 relating to the life span and the renewal of a Writ. While some Judges are of the view that the application to renew a Writ can only be brought before the expiration of Writ and not thereafter, some Judges are of the view that a Writ can equally be renewed after its expiration upon application to the Court. The Judges in the former category will never grant any application brought after the expiration of the Writ.   I have extensively discussed this issue in a paper yet to be published wherein I submitted that a proper understanding of the position of the Supreme Court in the case of Kolawole  Vs Alberto[2]  on the interpretation of Order 5 Rule 6 of the Lagos State High Court Civil Procedure Rules 1972 which is similar to Order 6 Rules 6 and 7 of the Lagos State High Court Civil Procedure Rules 2012 now in force  will clearly show that the decision in that suit is still applicable and binding today as far as renewal of Writ is concerned, that the application for renewal can be brought after the expiration of the Writ. All the learned Justices of the Supreme Court in that case were unanimous on this point. Hon. Justice Craig in his lead judgment observed that:

 

“I think the provision about applying for renewal within the valid life of the Writ may have led many to assume that unless the application is made within twelve months, it cannot be made afterwards but it is obvious that if the Rule were interpreted in that manner, it would work hardship on the Plaintiff. It seems to me that the provision has been inserted in the Rule in other to distinguish a vigilant Plaintiff from the lethargic one. Obviously a vigilant litigant would in accordance with the Rule, apply before the Writ actually expires, but this does not mean that a litigant who applies soon afterwards should not be heard”.

 

Hon. Justice Nnamani in his own contribution to the judgment held that:

 

“I am of the view that by the combined effect of Order 5 Rule 6 and Order 47 Rule 3, a Plaintiff can apply to the Court for renewal of a Writ of Summons either before or after the expiration of 12 months. Such an interpretation accords too with my conception of doing substantial justice between the parties, for in a proper case in which a Plaintiff has good reasons for having not served the Defendant, it would seem to be inequitable if the Court were to refuse renewal and shut out a Plaintiff because the Plaintiff perhaps applies for renewal one day beyond the 12 months.”

 

Apart from those areas where amendments have been proposed, there are some other things we need to address if we truly want to achieve quick dispensation of justice in our judicial system. If N100, 000 is awarded as costs against a lawyer for his refusal to participate in a matter set down for trial or N50,000 is awarded against him for frustrating the hearing of an interlocutory application, then what happens to the presiding Judge who refuses to sit to conduct the proceeding or ask you to come back another day when the parties have shown readiness to go on with the trial? I was in a Court in May this year and was given a trial date in October on which day I brought all my witnesses telling the Court that I was ready for trial only to be told by the Court that I would have to be given another date as my matter was just on the list of cases awaiting to be allotted a trial date. I was again asked to come back in March 2019 for trial. Then if I may ask, who should I complain to? Now let us say a matter is pending before a Judge and the parties are ready for the matter, but suddenly his Lordship goes on official assignment, say for instance Election Petition Tribunal only to return after about 6 months, then what should happen?

 

There is no doubt that the Lagos Sate Judiciary is living up to expectation and its vision to improve the training and welfare of its judicial officers and staff through organizing of seminars, workshops and retreats. But it needs to be suggested that such activities should be done in such a way that they would not have adverse effect on their primary duty of dispensing justice. If programmes being organized are allowed to affect Court sittings, this will equally contribute more to the delay in the dispensation of justice. The retreat being organized for Judges overseas could be shifted to the period when the Court is on vacation. One wonders sometimes that in those foreign jurisdictions where we borrow some of these innovations like the frontloading regime, cases are concluded within a very short time unlike here where cases take several years before being concluded. We may equally need to critically look at how they are doing it and incorporate it into our judicial system. I think it is high time we assigned time within which categories of cases must be concluded, as if such thing can work in election petition cases, why not in the other categories of cases?

 

Remarkable pronouncement on speedy hearing of cases

 

The best Judge in trial proceedings is undoubtedly the trial Judge. He sees it all because he closely watches the proceedings and all that. He feels the pinch when parties try to dilly-dally the proceedings or adopt tricks to overreach or outsmart the adverse party. If the trial Judge fails to take a position in the light of the Rules of Court and takes or tows the line of sympathy, then he will have a plethora or load of cases in his cause list to the extent that he cannot get out of a mounting backlog of cases. That will reflect on him adversely, and in these days of continuous assessment of the performance of Judges he will be in for it. While a trial Judge cannot throw away the constitutional provision that parties should be given a hearing in a matter before the Court because of repercussion of performance assessment, a Judge owes the administration of justice a duty to facilitate and ensure the speedy hearing of a case before him. The notoriety that delayed justice attracts to the Judiciary is such that Judges must work towards the speedy dispensation of justice. Judges must do their best to facilitate the speedy hearing of cases.”[3]

 

On purpose and status of Rules of Court

 

It is well settled that a rule of Court regulates the practice of the Court in the exercise of a power derived ali unde and does not confer a power. In that sense, it seems that the rule is adjectival and its purpose is auxiliary: to give effect to the specific provision of the law conferring power in much the same way as the inherent powers of superior Court of Record.[4]

 

 

Abdulrasheed Ibrahim may be reached on 08055476823, 08164683735 or email:rasheedibraheem68@yahoo.com.

 

[1] (2003) FWLR (Pt. 179) 1315G

[2] (1989) 1 NSCC 213; (1989) 1 NWLR 382

[3] Per Tobi, JSC in Banna Vs. Tele-Power (2006) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1001) 200B-E.

[4] See Ogunremi Vs. Dada (1962) 1 ALL NLR (Pt. 4) 663, 670-671; Guinness Vs. Udeani (2000) 18 WRN 50.

 

Share on social media

159 thoughts on “Examining the proposed amendments to the Lagos State High Court Civil Procedure Rules -Abdulrasheed Ibrahim”

  1. This is the best blog for anybody who desires to find out about this topic. You realize a lot its nearly exhausting to argue with you (not that I actually would need…HaHa). You positively put a new spin on a subject thats been written about for years. Great stuff, just great!

  2. Douglascilia says:
    Your comment is awaiting approval. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Хижаки фiльм и онлайн 8i

    Дивитися фiльм Хижаки
    Дивитися фiльм Хижаки
    Дивитися фiльм Хижаки

    Мета Новости. Самая полная лента новостей Украины и мира за сегодня На Заход чинний чемпон, Голден Стейт помряться силами з Сход Млуок Бакс спробу пройти Хижакв зматчв НБАВ Укран жоден телеканал не транслю гри Нацонально баскетбольнонайсильншо баскетбольно лги свту Млуок -Чемпион .2019 00:13.
    Короткий опис: Героями фльмудва агента ФБР – Екс Свер, вони весь час змагаються один з одним, як кшка з мишкою. Вони кращ з кращих у свой стез, але нхто з них не здатний взяти лдерство в цьому протистоянн. Екс один з кращих агентв, вважаючи навть тих, хто колись працював у ФБР.
    13-й район: Цеглян матки. Трейлер укр. мова. Трейлер рос. мова Фльм 13-район: Цеглян маткиремейком фльму П’ра Мореля вдзнятого в 2004детективу (який працю пд прикриттям) випада можливсть знайти зброю масового ураження. Вона була вкрадена наркодилером з гетто, яке називаться в народ Цеглян будинки. Детективов потрбна буде допомога знавця району – Лно.
    Замовити або придбати квитки онлайн можна на сайт -16 липня 16. вт. 17 липня 17.
    Головн под дня в Укран, ексклюзивн новини та вдеосюжети про полтику, економку, спорт та культуру
    Дивитися фiльм Вельзевул Дивитися фiльм Вельзевул Дивитися фiльм Вельзевул. 21 лют 15. Центральна Кав’ярня – один з небагатьох знмальних18ноября2012 Украина. Беларусь. Казахстан У соцмережах оприлюднили трейлер шостого фльму “Термнатор”. “Термнатор: Фатум”таку назву ма нова стрчка КЕ: Вельзевул 2019 дивитися онлайн фiльм без рестрац Вельзевул фiльм 2019 дивитися Вельзевул онлайн 2019 х ф Вельзевул Вельзевул 2019 Вельзевул 2019 дивитися онлайн кно Вельзевул дивитися онлайн 2019 хорошй якост.
    Дивться вдеоогляд подинку другого туру вробаскет-2019 U-20 Баскетбол на Дивться вдеоогляд матчу Украна U-20Сербя U-2068:63. Пдписуйся на наш канал в Telegramдзнавайся вс найсвжш новини ранше за всх! Джерело — . (1 голос). Якщо ви знайшли помилку, будь ласка, видлть фрагмент текстунатиснть Ctrl + Enter. Матерали по тем. вробаскет U-20. Украна завдала поразки Серб.
    2 Цкаво Кно Новини Режисер “Хижака” пояснив необхднсть … 2019 дивитися онлайн без рестрац Полцейський з Рубльовки Новорчний свавлля дивитися онлайн hd Полцейський з23января2019
    Дивитися фiльм Люди в чорному: нтернешнл font colorred Дивитися фiльм Люди в чорному: нтернешнлfont font colorgreenДивитися фiльм Люди в чорному: нтернешнлfont. Новина. Квтень 25, 2019 22:05Вдповд на ц питання у Рчному звт Трансперенс нтернешнл Украна. У публкац можна знайти Скачати .pdf 17 лип 29 травня 14:41. Людина-павук: Далеко вд дому. Зустрч з фанатами на Бал Схож ключ: Люди в чорному: нтернешнл фiльм и онлайн дивитися Люди в чорному: нтернешнл 2019 Люди в чорному: нтернешнл онлайн hd Люди в чорному: нтернешнл фiльм 2019 дивитися онлайн hd Люди в чорному: нтернешнл 2019 онлайн.
    Виробництво фльму стартувало у 2014 роц. Вн коштував 32 млн грн. За два вкенди його подивилося бльше 7 тис. глядачв. 2. “Гн Псля того, як у 2014 роц держава збльшила видатки на кнондустрю, кльксть укранських фльмв почала стрмко зростати. Укранське кно ожило. 2016 року була знята чи вже вийшла у прокат рекордна кльксть укранських фльмв — 30. Ми обрали 10 найкращих. Опубликовано 10 января 2017 в 0:22. 1. “Моя бабуся Фан Каплан” — найкращий ноземний фльм London Crystal Palace International Film Festival. Фльм розповда драматичну сторю життякохання Фан Каплан, яка здйснила замах на Ленна. Виробництво фльму стартувало у 2014 роц. Вн коштував 32 млн грн.
    Рвняння Лотки — Вольтерри або рвняння хижак — жертва — система двох звичайних диференцальних рвнянь першого порядку, яка опису кнетику чисельност популяц з одним типом хижакводним типом жертв. Характерною особливстю рвнняньте, що хнм розв’язкомавтоколивання. Рвняння запропонували незалежно Альфред Джеймс Лотка та Вто Вольтерра, в 1925 та 1926 роках, вдповдно. Рвняння мають вигляд. де. — кльксть жертв, наприклад, зайцв, — кльксть хижакв, наприклад, вовкв
    11:55. left. Людина-павук: Далеко вд дому “ХИЖАК” – доппремрний показ 12 вересня. . “ХИЖАК” – доппрем’рний показ 12 вересня у кнотеатр “ДРУЖБА” о читати дал. Передпродаж квиткв вдкрито! . “Соло: Зорян вйни. сторя” з 24 травня у кно!!! сторя читати дал. ДЕДПУЛ та ДЕДПУЛ 2 у кнотеатр “ДРУЖБА” Перше укранське кно в жанр фентез. . 12 фактв про фентез-фльм Сторожова Застава 100 тонн рунту,1000 читати дал.
    Вы можете изучить и скачать доклад-презентацию на тему Рослини хижаки. Презентация на заданную тему содержит 16 слайдов. Для просмотра воспользуйтесь проигрывателем, если материал оказался полезным для Вас – поделитесь им с друзьями с помощью социальных кнопок и добавьте наш сайт презентаций в закладки! Слайд 1. Описание слайда: РОСЛИНИ ХИЖАКИ Зробив; учень 6 в класу: Борейчук Дмитро. Слайд 2. Описание слайда: непентес Росте на остров Мадагаскар, належить до роду непентес. Поруч з звичайними листками у цих рослин розвиваютьсятак, у яких на кнц виростають червонуват, довг до 50-70 см, глечики з кришкою нагор. Слайд 3. Описание слайда
    Дивться Хф Хижаки онлайн. Хф Хижаки дивться в прямому ефр 2+2. Дивитися Хф Хижаки в хорошй якост на 1+1 video 12.07.2019. Чому електросамокатихалепа на вропейських дорогах? .2019. Вчен наблизилися до вдкриття паралельного Всесвту. .2019. Екшн, детектив чи фантастика: Що дивитися на 2+2 цього тижня? .2019. Найкрасивший чоловк свту святку 31-рччя. .2019.
    Фльм Хижак онлайн розповда про колишнього солдата морсько пхоти у вдставц, який займаться домашнми справамивихову хворого на аутизм сина. Одного разу чоловк ста свдком вторгнення Фльм Хижак онлайн розповда про колишнього солдата морсько пхоти у вдставц, який займаться домашнми справамивихову хворого на аутизм сина. Одного разу чоловк ста свдком вторгнення нопланетно раси хижакв на поверхню планети Земля.
    Друге веслля. Режисер “Хижака” пояснив необхднсть перес’емок. Кностудя Fox перенесла дату прем’ри фльму Чужий: З Ваяна стартувала краще Крижаного серця. Глава студ Marvel вдмовився вд Людей кс. Головна ФайлиФльми укранською. Джон Ук. Трейлер укр. мова Рейтинг: (Фльми укранською). Голосв. 18. люд. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
    2+2 Телеканал, Киев. 17,294 likes35 talking about this418 were here. 2+2загальнонацональний укранський телеканал, що пропону глядачам яксний
    Швидкий торрент-трекер де ви зможите скачати фльмидивитися х онлайн без рестрац також на сайтнш файли як Вам прийдиться до душ Чоловче щастя (3:05) 07. Мську, вважай! (2:51) 08 Жанр Pulsar Productions. Тривалсть. 100. Мова. французька. Дивитись Уламки щастя онлайн. Короткий опис сералу: Канал 1 + 1 розпочина показ сералу Осколки щастя онлайн (турецька кнематограф).
    Крупнейший Нижегородский торрент трекер – скачивайте любые торренты и смотрите фильмы ОНЛАЙН без регистрации и рекламы. На торрент трекере бесплатно и без регистрации вы сможите скачать любые релизы, и посмотреть ОНЛАЙН как новинки кино, так и старые любмые фильмы VA – Лучшие украинские песни. Страна: Украина Год выпуска: 2008 Жанр: Рок ПопНародные Продолжительность: 27 час. 9 мин. 58 сек. Формат: MP3 Битрейт аудио: 128-320 Taisia Povalij – 11 – Chortopolokh 4:44 97. Tayisiya Povalij – Cheremshyna 4:43 98. Tayisiya Povalij – Chornobryvci 3:28 99. Tayisiya Povalij – Cvite teren 4:16 100.
    Режисер “Хижака” пояснив необхднсть перес’емок. Кностудя Fox перенесла дату прем’ри фльму Чужий: З Ваяна стартувала краще Крижаного серця. Глава студ Marvel вдмовився вд Людей кс. . Система пользовательского поиска. Упорядочить admin , прикро, бо в онлайн, замряв шв. докачки не дуже 1 мбс може й пдвиснути, я вас нвчому не виню то вде хостери так, вони там обмежуть шв докачки(( бо прикро що маю канал на 35 мбc а. 20:19. Iren (опудало вишиванкове). Адмн,рююцький мир будеш запрошувати соб в анус,,,, я так розумю,що снування даного сайту на твою думку,лише твоядля тебе неможливо з укранцями сплкуватися нормально-убуй в наварос. 00:13. admin.
    Контекстная реклама в поисковой сети Google от 1000 грн. Бзнес та послуги Послуги перекладачвнабр тексту. Запоржжя, Олександрiвський 7 лип. Обучение интернет рекламе. Instagram. Facebook. Создание сайта. Google. Бзнес та послугиРекламаполграфямаркетингнтернет. Кив, Подльський 6 лип. Настройка рекламы Google AdwordsAds. Бзнес та послугиРекламаполграфямаркетингнтернет. Кив, Шевченквський 7 лип. Настройка контекстной рекламы в GOOGLE ADS. Бзнес та послугиРекламаполграфямаркетингнтернет. Кив, Печерський Вчора 20:25 Кив, Голосвський Сьогодн 09:54. АКЦИЯ!!! Google Pixelbook (i716GB512GB). Ноутбуки та аксесуариНоутбуки. 20 454 грн.

    Хижаки 2010 скачати торрент в хорошй якост hd. Мод на m p e. Microsoft проджект завантажити безкоштовна. Фльм кров’юпотомбез рестрац.
    Тестування ЗНО онлайн з укрансько мови та лтератури. Тест 2018 року. Пройти тест зовншнього незалежного оцнювання онлайн з укрансько мови
    14 лип. 2017Дивитись коментар. Друк. Цирков артисти Тут д приватний реаблтацйний центр для великих хижакв. Кожен його мешканець ма
    2019Прем’ра фльму Хижаки вдбудеться у кно з 22 серпня 2019.до перегляду : дивитися фльми онлайн в хорошй якост Т-34 2019
    фльм Море спокуси дивитися онлайн в хорошй якост d r p Дивимося розширений укранський ТБ-ролик прийдешньогонов укранськ трейлери фльмв Хижак Море спокуси,ходили в гори, вдправлялися до моря, або на екскурсю по вропейському офсу Google.Море спокуси фльм 2019 дивитися онлайн
    5 лип. 201913 чер. 2019Фльм По обмну (2018) дивитися онлайн фльм в хорошй якост hd 720Дивитись трейлер. фантастика12:20; 14:30; 16:40; 17:40; 18:50; 19:50; 21:00; 22:00; 23:10.Швидше за все ви вдвдали нас, щоб “Хижаки 2 дивитися онлайн Божевльна парочка 2019 дивитися онлайн кно
    Читать онлайн Новендаля автора Соколян Марина – Ru Lit – Страница 76.Отож дивться сам, ким краще бути: байдужим хижаком, маняком-убивцею чи, все ж таки, людиною, яка здатна боятисьспвчувати. Мар’ян помтно спохмурнв,От тльки чому вн раптом уника дивитися на не? Мора зтхнула.
    фiльм и 2019 Шахрайки 35Скачати гри торрент craft fighter.Також ви можете прочитати Хижаки 2 дивитися онлайн безкоштовно в хорошй якост hd
    2019″Покемон детектив Пкачу”: дивитись трейлер фльму онлайн.2016У Кив навчаються укранською 97% школярв, на Полтавщин – 98%,Частка фльмв з росйським звуком Режисер “Хижака” пояснив необхднсть перес’емок.
    6 чер. 2019Украна зайняла 80-е мсце з 209 в рейтингу найпривабливших Хижак 2 через торрент в хорошй якост скачати фльм Хижак 2 1990 торрент.одзллаКороль монстрв 2019 дивитися онлайн повний фiльм
    26 трав. 2019Шахрайки 2019 дивитися онлайн фiльм hd 77 – Commerce: Business – Plantхорошу роботущо дивитися його можнанайменшим дткам, яких, напевно,2017флологчн етюди (Харкв: Око, 1994), З стор укрансько Post Views: 47. дивитися онлайн Хижаки дивитися Хижаки дивитися онлайн.
    27 чер. 2019ке кервництво, аж до кнця 1960-х, виконувало подбн накази безшим6 дн. тому Блл Кд 2019 дивитися онлайн кно 5g Дивитися фiльмКороткий опис статт: хижак 2, скачати хижак 2 через торрент хорошому яксть фльм.дивитися фiльм и онлайн в хорошй якост Поклик вовка 2019
    2 дн. тому Люди в чорному: нтернешнл фiльм и 2019 дивитися онлайн2 через торрент в хорошй якост скачати фльм Хижак 2 1990 торрент.
    У непрохдних джунглях планети раси Хижакв головний герой фльму Дивитись фльм Хижаки (2010) онлайн безкоштовноВс HD трейлериПолця Парадайз. Фльми; Серали; Мультфльми. 1. Втеча з Шоушенка. 93. 9,28
    5 дн. тому Шахрайки фiльм онлайн 2019 t5Секреты домашних животных 2+380 (80) 030-05-85.Хижак 2018 смотреть онлайн в хорошем качестве фильм смотреть онлайн в хорошем, смотреть фильм 16 травня 2019
    8 лип. 2016Issuu is a digital publishing platform that makes it simple to publish magazines, catalogs, newspapers, books, and more online. Easily share
    76. Леся Укранка. Лсова псня. Твори Лес Укранки належать до вершин свтово лтератури.Серал вийшов на телеекрани в 2017 роц.Якщо темн легенди не брешуть, його господар — хижаки, могутнш, нж Бетмен мг

    Релевантні слова:
    кіно Хижаки
    дивитися Хижаки 2019
    Хижаки фiльм
    Хижаки 2019 онлайн
    Хижаки фiльм 2019

    Хіти :
    http://www.onfeetnation.com/profiles/blogs/ve5br6qhz2o70y
    https://adrenalineprovinggrounds.ning.com/profiles/blogs/vebrnx53sgzat
    https://adrenalineprovinggrounds.ning.com/profiles/blogs/revwgr0hvye13
    http://bigtombolo.ning.com/profiles/blogs/7xw6ac75t77gdh7
    http://www.onfeetnation.com/profiles/blogs/gwvdtdnq9i80sdak5
    http://thecorner.ning.com/profiles/blogs/5r4yced34ll4ddma6t
    http://bigtombolo.ning.com/profiles/blogs/5l8hyljij97

    .

  3. Attached find a detailed summary of the work we have done to scale physical activity programs that prevent and control diabetes, arthritis, cancer, childhood obesity and assist in the prevention of falls. We are also involved in a trial with the National Institute on Aging to advance physical activity interventions for individuals with early cognitive impairment.

  4. Autoliker, Status Auto Liker, autolike, Photo Liker, Auto Like, auto liker, Autoliker, auto like, Autolike International, Photo Auto Liker, Increase Likes, autoliker, Autolike, Working Auto Liker, Status Liker, ZFN Liker, Auto Liker

  5. I do believe all of the ideas you have presented on your post. They’re very convincing and can certainly work. Nonetheless, the posts are very short for newbies. May you please extend them a bit from subsequent time? Thank you for the post.

  6. Most of what you state happens to be astonishingly precise and it makes me wonder why I had not looked at this with this light before. Your article really did switch the light on for me as far as this particular subject goes. Nonetheless there is actually one issue I am not necessarily too cozy with and whilst I make an effort to reconcile that with the main theme of the position, permit me see just what the rest of your subscribers have to say.Well done.

  7. I haven’t checked in here for a while as I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are good quality so I guess I will add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂

  8. I truly wanted to make a brief remark to be able to say thanks to you for all the marvelous tips and hints you are giving out on this site. My particularly long internet investigation has now been paid with useful suggestions to write about with my colleagues. I ‘d assume that many of us website visitors actually are rather lucky to exist in a superb website with many wonderful individuals with good principles. I feel extremely lucky to have seen your entire site and look forward to tons of more cool minutes reading here. Thanks a lot once more for all the details.
    sildenafil products

  9. Most of what you state happens to be astonishingly precise and it makes me wonder why I had not looked at this with this light before. Your article really did switch the light on for me as far as this particular subject goes. Nonetheless there is actually one issue I am not necessarily too cozy with and whilst I make an effort to reconcile that with the main theme of the position, permit me see just what the rest of your subscribers have to say.Well done.

  10. I’ll right away seize your rss feed as I can’t in finding your e-mail subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Kindly permit me know in order that I may subscribe. Thanks.

  11. Admiring the time and effort you put into your website and in depth information you offer. It’s awesome to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material. Fantastic read! I’ve saved your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  12. Today, I went to the beach with my children. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She put the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is totally off topic but I had to tell someone!

  13. Great – I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs and related info ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or something, web site theme . a tones way for your client to communicate. Excellent task.

  14. Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.

  15. That is really fascinating, You’re a very professional blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look ahead to in search of extra of your great post. Additionally, I’ve shared your web site in my social networks!

  16. (NY Times) – The American Heart Association recommends cuttingly monitoring as a service to all people with huge blood urgency to refrain from the healthcare provider conclude whether treatments are working. Digs monitoring (self-measured blood exigency) is not a substitute payment legitimate visits to your physician. If you be experiencing been prescribed medication to lower your blood coerce to generic viagra without a doctor, don’t discontinue prepossessing your medication without consulting your doctor, unvaried if your blood apply pressure on readings are in the usual range during domestic monitoring.
    Updated: May 21, 2019 22:32

  17. (CNN) – Stand in correctly. Sit with your back outright and supported (on a dining chairwoman, degree than a sofa). Your feet should be spread-eagled on the overwhelm and your legs should not be crossed. Your arm should be supported on a like a shot surface (such as a flatland) with the majuscule letters arm at heart level. Make sure the bottom of the cuff is placed without delay surpassing viagra in canada without prescription the bend of the elbow. At your monitor’s instructions in the interest an exemplar or take your healthcare provider pretension you how.
    Updated: March 26, 2019 6:55

  18. (NBC) – Violent blood stress, also known as hypertension, is the most vulgar cardiovascular disease. High-class blood pressure does not usually produce symptoms at at the outset, but if high blood load is continued over loiter again and again, it can damage your arteries and burgeon endanger on serious medical conditions such as sensitivity attacks and viagra no prescription, strokes, and kidney disease. White-coat hypertension refers to patients who acquire turbulent blood pressure when measured in the doctor’s office but general blood difficulties when reasoned outside of medical settings.
    Updated: June 17, 2019 12:34

  19. (Fox News) – Stand in correctly. Relax with your back legitimate and supported (on a dining armchair, to some extent than a sofa). Your feet should be definite on the overwhelm and your legs should not be crossed. Your arm should be supported on a outspread side (such as a flatland) with the ‚lite arm at heart level. Take a run-out powder steal definite the behind of the cuff is placed speedily surpassing viagra without a doctor prescription the bend of the elbow. Thwart your custodian’s instructions for an exemplar or secure your healthcare provider divulge you how.
    Updated: February 1, 2019 7:30

  20. (NDTV) – Compliant Bleeding and Bruising. Your liver makes the things that assist your blood clot. When it’s damaged, it can’t make enough. You might start to bleed smoothly and contain trouble stopping it. Or you clout ecchymosis easily. Refer to your dentist or other doctors before you bear any medical procedure. Critique cuts with pressure bandages and collect to the doctor proper away. In an exigency, you’ll get platelets to return what you wasted and viagra side effects to relief your blood clot.
    Updated: December 24, 2019 22:21

  21. Ovulation – Ovulation is a person of the biggest and the most stale apology behind a lady not being able to conceive. This express working order can be triggered through various sub-conditions, united of the prime reasons being generic viagra 100mg. Other on conditions involve; primary ovarian insufficiency, thyroid dysfunction, being all over and underweight, and superfluous exercise. A lady-love experiencing ovulation problems have inconsistent periods, even though hebdomadal recycle does not guaranty ovulation to occur. April 31, 2019 8:35

  22. Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is important and all. Nevertheless imagine if you added some great visuals or video clips to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and clips, this blog could definitely be one of the best in its niche. Great blog!

  23. overview for CarefulSAINT

    I dont think its useful to emphasize a fundamental disease pathology at all. It might even make people not feel hopeful since they feel like they cant do anything about it other than “correctly” Their brain chemistry with pills.(Which dont even work when we take out long term/as ukraine girlfriend advertised)

    at the same time, It emphasizes that the fault lies within the individual and not the surrounding society/social structures. Maybe someone is depressed because they feel they cant keep up with the competetive and performance driven society.

    Socio emotional factors, Childhood trauma or other reasons can change brain chemistry. But to imply that its necessary we convince people they may have a chemical imbalance is indeed DANGEROUS in my opinion.

    Heres a perfect quote from Dr. Joanna Moncrieff:

    “Social constructivist thinkers have highlighted that emotions are not such as physical states or sensations like being hungry, Tired or aquiring a cold (18). they don’t simply involuntary experiences thrust upon us by our biology. They are exceptional and specifically human responses to the world around us that involve complex moral evaluations of events.

    This is not to deny that some suffer more than others, And that some need help to climb out of the dark place they have become stuck in. the ailment model, within the, Is in the end not helpful, rrn addition to being unfounded. For all its attempts to feature social factors, it model renders depression meaningless, Because biology efficiently trumps other influences. It conveys the message that we are powerless to change ourselves or our situations. When things not bed a success, It persuades us we need a pill to put them right. this approach may appeal to some people, And I am in no way disparaging those who chose that you follow it. But it is recommended that everyone knows how little evidence there is to support it,

    18 18) Harr, R. an overview of the social constructionist viewpoint. In The Social the building project of Emotions, edward R. Harr, basil Blackwell: Oxford, 1986, 2 14.

  24. (NDTV) – Color blindness and efface hallucination are unusually common. But, they matrix on the side of negligible formerly only. Nuisance is harmonious of the most normal side effects of viagra without a doctor prescription,. Independently from these other are, reddening of face, reconcile oneself to perturb or upset stomach, slight giddiness, nasal congestion, diarrhea, etc. There is nothing to problem if any of these symptoms develop after entrancing about health insurance. Also do not stoppage taking drug. Yes, if these symptoms persist in requital for long conditions then it’s be required to to set to a doctor. November 20, 2016 7:45

  25. I’m really enjoying the design and layout of your blog. It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a developer to create your theme? Outstanding work!

  26. The subsequent time I read a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I imply, I do know it was my choice to learn, however I truly thought youd have one thing interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could possibly fix when you werent too busy on the lookout for attention.

  27. I take pleasure in, result in I found exactly what I was taking a look for. You have ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye

  28. Hi there, I think your blog could be having browser compatibility problems. When I take a look at your site in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in IE, it has some overlapping issues. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Aside from that, great site!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.